| Andrew Cooke | Contents | Latest | RSS | Twitter | Previous | Next

C[omp]ute

Welcome to my blog, which was once a mailing list of the same name and is still generated by mail. Please reply via the "comment" links.

Always interested in offers/projects/new ideas. Eclectic experience in fields like: numerical computing; Python web; Java enterprise; functional languages; GPGPU; SQL databases; etc. Based in Santiago, Chile; telecommute worldwide. CV; email.

Personal Projects

Lepl parser for Python.

Colorless Green.

Photography around Santiago.

SVG experiment.

Professional Portfolio

Calibration of seismometers.

Data access via web services.

Cache rewrite.

Extending OpenSSH.

C-ORM: docs, API.

Last 100 entries

Why Are There Still So Many Jobs?; Navier Stokes Incomplete; More on Benford; FBI Claimed Vandalism; Architectural Tessellation; Also: Go, Blake's 7; Delusions of Gender (book); Crypto AG DID work with NSA / GCHQ; UNUMS (Universal Number Format); MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses); Interesting Looking Game; Euler's Theorem for Polynomials; Weeks 3-6; Reddit Comment; Differential Cryptanalysis For Dummies; Japanese Graphic Design; Books To Be Re-Read; And Today I Learned Bugs Need Clear Examples; Factoring a 67 bit prime in your head; Islamic Geometric Art; Useful Julia Backtraces from Tasks; Nothing, however, is lost with less discomfort than that which, when lost, cannot be missed; Article on Didion; Cost of Living by City; British Slavery; Derrida on Metaphor; African SciFi; Traits in Julia; Alternative Japanese Lit; Pulic Key as Address (Snow); Why Information Grows; The Blindness Of The Chilean Elite; Some Victoriagate Links; This Is Why I Left StackOverflow; New TLS Implementation; Maths for Physicists; How I Am 8; 1000 Word Philosophy; Cyberpunk Reading List; Detailed Discussion of Message Dispatch in ParserCombinator Library for Julia; FizzBuzz in Julia w Dependent Types; kokko - Design Shop in Osaka; Summary of Greece, Currently; LLVM and GPUs; See Also; Schoolgirl Groyps (Maths); Japanese Lit; Another Example - Modular Arithmetic; Music from United; Python 2 and 3 compatible alternative.; Read Agatha Christie for the Plot; A Constructive Look at TempleOS; Music Thread w Many Recommendations; Fixed Version; A Useful Julia Macro To Define Equality And Hash; k3b cdrom access, OpenSuse 13.1; Week 2; From outside, the UK looks less than stellar; Huge Fonts in VirtualBox; Keen - Complex Emergencies; The Fallen of World War II; Some Spanish Fiction; Calling C From Fortran 95; Bjork DJ Set; Z3 Example With Python; Week 1; Useful Guide To Starting With IJulia; UK Election + Media; Review: Reinventing Organizations; Inline Assembly With Julia / LLVM; Against the definition of types; Dumb Crypto Paper; The Search For Quasi-Periodicity...; Is There An Alternative To Processing?; CARDIAC (CARDboard Illustrative Aid to Computation); The Bolivian Case Against Chile At The Hague; Clear, Cogent Economic Arguments For Immigration; A Program To Say If I Am Working; Decent Cards For Ill People; New Photo; Luksic And Barrick Gold; President Bachelet's Speech; Baltimore Primer; libxml2 Parsing Stream; configure.ac Recipe For Library Path; The Davalos Affair For Idiots; Not The Onion: Google Fireside Chat w Kissinger; Bicycle Wheels, Inertia, and Energy; Another Tax Fraud; Google's Borg; A Verion That Redirects To Local HTTP Server; Spanish Accents For Idiots; Aluminium Cans; Advice on Spray Painting; Female View of Online Chat From a Male; UX Reading List; S4 Subgroups - Geometric Interpretation; Fucking Email; The SQM Affair For Idiots; Using Kolmogorov Complexity; Oblique Strategies in bash

© 2006-2015 Andrew Cooke (site) / post authors (content).

O(n) and O(n^2) in a Dynamic Programming Problem

From: andrew cooke <andrew@...>

Date: Sat, 6 Aug 2011 14:39:51 -0400

I posted an answer at
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/6967853/dynamic-programing-can-interval-of-even-1s-and-0s-be-found-in-linear-time
that I want to copy here, beause I am worried that it will be deleted by the
moderators.

The question asks for a linear solution to a problem which generates O(N^2)
results.  That seems impossible, but if you look in more detail there's a cute
argument that hinges on the difference between "finding" and "printing" the
results:


A linear solution is possible (sorry, earlier I argued that this had to be
n^2) if you're careful to not actually print the results!

First, let's define a "score" for any set of zeros and ones as the number of
ones minus the number of zeroes.  So (0,1) has a score of 0, while (0) is -1
and (1,1) is 2.

Now, start from the right.  If the right-most digit is a 0 then it can be
combined with any group to the left that has a score of 1.  So we need to know
what groups are available to the left, indexed by score.  This suggests a
recursive procedure that accumulates groups with scores.  The sweep process is
O(n) and at each step the process has to check whether it has created a new
group and extend the table of known groups.  Checking for a new group is
constant time (lookup in a hash table).  Extending the table of known groups
is also constant time (at first I thought it wasn't, but you can maintain a
separate offset that avoids updating each entry in the table).

So we have a peculiar situation: each step of the process identifies a set of
results of size O(n), but the calculation necessary to do this is constant
time (within that step).  So the process itself is still O(n) (proportional to
the number of steps).  Of course, actually printing the results is O(n^2).

I'll write some Python code to test/demonstrate.

Here we go:

    SCORE = [-1,1]
    
    class Accumulator:
    
        def __init__(self):
            self.offset = 0
            self.groups_to_right = {} # map from score to start index
            self.even_groups = []
            self.index = 0
    
        def append(self, digit):
            score = SCORE[digit]
            # want existing groups at -score, to sum to zero
            # but there's an offset to correct for, so we really want
            # groups at -(score+offset)
            corrected = -(score + self.offset)
            if corrected in self.groups_to_right:
                self.even_groups.append(
                    (self.index, self.groups_to_right[corrected]))
            # this updates all the known groups
            self.offset += score
            # this adds the new one, which should be at the index so that
            # index + offset = score (so index = score - offset)
            groups = self.groups_to_right.get(score-self.offset, [])
            groups.append(self.index) 
            self.groups_to_right[score-self.offset] = groups
            # and move on
            self.index += 1
            #print self.offset
            #print self.groups_to_right
            #print self.even_groups
            #print self.index
    
        def dump(self):
            # printing the results does take longer, of course...
            for (end, starts) in self.even_groups:
                for start in starts:
                    if start < end:
                        print (start, end)
    
        @staticmethod
        def run(input):
            accumulator = Accumulator()
            print input
            for digit in input:
                accumulator.append(digit)
            accumulator.dump()
            print
    
    Accumulator.run([0,1,0,0,1,1,1,1,0])

And the output:

    dynamic: python dynamic.py 
    [0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0]
    (0, 1)
    (1, 2)
    (1, 4)
    (3, 4)
    (0, 5)
    (2, 5)
    (7, 8)

You might be worried that some additional processing (the filtering for `start
< end`) is done in the dump routine that displays the results.  But that's
because I am working around Python's lack of linked lists (I want to both
extend a list and save the previous value in constant time).

It may seem surprising that the result is of *size* O(n^2) while the process
of *finding* the results is O(n), but it's easy to see how that is possible:
at one "step" the process identifies a number of groups (of size O(n)) by
associating the current point (`end` in `dump()`) with a list of end points
(`ends`).


Andrew

Comment on this post