From: "andrew cooke" <andrew@...>
Date: Mon, 14 Jul 2008 23:11:46 -0400 (CLT)
How long before version control for source becomes semantic-based? In other words, when will diffs become actions like "move method" or "rename variable" rather than syntactic changes? It will need closer integration between IDE and VCS - probably a standard abstract syntax representation. It might also require a certain kind of language (in some ways this would be much easier with Lisp, for example, but I am thinking more of a language which emphasises semantic chunks, although I have no idea what that actually means). A quick google turns up some work on adding an extra layer of abstraction to the source (by modelling or ontologies), if I understand correctly, but there doesn't seem to be anything close to what I sketch above. IntelliJ is heading this way and I was impressed (although I am now back in the land of the free Eclipse, largely because it has better Python support). I wonder if they are considering something like this? I guess it's still too far down the line. Andrew